Dirk Hawthorne
Well-known member
I had to replace my original extractor after about 10,000 rounds. I wish I had kept a more exact round count.
It looks exactly the same as the new one, but the new one definitely fit tighter in its lair in the bolt.
I was thinking maybe give it a tiny bend with a lump hammer and a vice and see if it will work good again. They're expensive now!
I'm an engineer and I can tell you for certain that "spring set" is a thing. Steel springs relax under load, over time. It's called "creep." When we design prestressed concrete beams, we allow about 20% loss of force in the prestressing strands to account for creep in the steel strands and the concrete beam.
How many rounds are you getting out of an extractor?
I also tried testing the recoil spring using the gun weight method. A new spring keeps the bolt almost closed, while the old one allows it to open about 3/8" of an inch. Still works OK.
It looks exactly the same as the new one, but the new one definitely fit tighter in its lair in the bolt.
I was thinking maybe give it a tiny bend with a lump hammer and a vice and see if it will work good again. They're expensive now!
I'm an engineer and I can tell you for certain that "spring set" is a thing. Steel springs relax under load, over time. It's called "creep." When we design prestressed concrete beams, we allow about 20% loss of force in the prestressing strands to account for creep in the steel strands and the concrete beam.
How many rounds are you getting out of an extractor?
I also tried testing the recoil spring using the gun weight method. A new spring keeps the bolt almost closed, while the old one allows it to open about 3/8" of an inch. Still works OK.

